A significant portion of my livelihood is hurtling toward cancellation. It’s one of those bills that have been given a cutesy acronym name. As I was arguing to friends DECADE’S ago – just because you name a bill “The Orphans and Puppies Aid Act” does NOT mean that the bill has ANYTHING to do with, let alone aid, either orphans OR puppies. (If you’re one of those despicable cat people please substitute “kitties” for “puppies” in the above so I don’t lose your support.) It’s called the PRO Act – Protecting the Right to Organize Act. And it has virtually nothing to do with the right to organize. It will more than likely kill the ride share industry as currently constituted.
Y’see most of us ALREADY have the right to organize and have chosen NOT to. We don’t WANT to. But the Great White Fathers (and Mothers …. ESPECIALLY Mothers) in far away Washington DC know better. They KNOW what we need and they’re going to see that we get it, good and hard. For those of you not aware of this bill or its predecessors, it’s a more-or-less mirror image of California’s AB5 which west coasters overwhelmingly defeated at the ballot box last fall. Essentially it does away with the freedom to work as an independent contractor and requires those who WERE IC’s to become employees. Do you know why most of us AREN’T employees? Because we don’t WANT to be. Just sayin’.
So the silliness of this bill STARTS with the fact that it purports to “protect the right to organize” but it DOES so by PROHIBITING the right NOT to organize (or to NOT organize … one of my editor friends wanna weigh in here?) The second silliness is the long-standing leftist belief that if they just pass a statute everyone will change their behavior in the direction the left wants them to and the world will be a better place. They seem not to realize that we are NOT pieces on a chess board who will move in specified ways and follow a strict set of rules. One woulda thought PPACA woulda taught them that lesson but these aren’t flatworms we’re dealing with here.
This thing passes the Senate and a LOT of people are going to be worse off and virtually NO ONE will be better off. The platforms will either shut down or face a severe restructuring that will make them not affordable to a majority of my passengers and an unattractive side gig option for most drivers.
Congress Should Not Follow California’s Example With PRO Act
The federal labor legislation that would kill my livelihood.
Livelihoods And The Congressional Thieves Who Want To Steal Them
And my final (?) quibble: in Cali they bill came larded with a TON of exemptions for special interests. Writers especially. With no exemptions this thing will hit ANYBODY who free-lances including substitute teachers, ride share drivers, food delivery drivers, most OTR truckers, and many others. Find hope and take action: Understanding AB5 carve-outs. I don’t know what to do and I don’t know what I WILL do …. but I’m scared. Really.
But hey, no more mean tweets, AmIRight?
<edit to add> and THIS popped into my news feed within seconds of hitting “publish” Why Democrats Need the PRO Act: Union Density, Mandatory Dues and Straight-Up Graft.